The big question is, how do you know when you should use a gradient elution instead of isocratic elution?
To me, the way I always put it is, you’ll know if you’re waiting forever for the last peak to come off, then you probably need an HPLC gradient.
Technical Insights
There’s a technical answer to this question. If all of your molecules have similar hydrophobicities, then you do not need a gradient. What this means is, if you did a gradient, we typically do what we call a scouting run, ranging from 10 to 100% methanol or 10 to 100% ACN (Acetonitrile). You observe where the molecules come off. If all of your peaks come off within 15% of one another, which means they’re all coming off within 15% methanol or ACN of one another, then you do not need a gradient. Would a gradient work? Sure. Would isocratic work? Sure. There’s more than one right answer.
Gradients vs. Isocratic: Choosing the Right Approach
So, if all your molecules have similar hydrophobicities, they’ll all come out in the exact same mobile phase, which is fantastic. Most of us, well, it depends on what we’re doing. If you’re dealing with unknowns or you have a wide range of hydrophobicities, you’re going to run an gradient. This means you’re going to start with a very weak mobile phase, high polarity, a lot of water, and then program up to a very strong mobile phase, which means 100% methanol or 100% ACN.
Advantages of Using Gradients
In doing that, we’ll be able to sweep basically everything. And not only do we get our molecules of interest, but the way I think of it is, during a gradient, at the end of the gradient, we’re cleaning off the column. So, during every run, I get a brand-new column because I just cleaned it. That’s the difference between a gradient versus isocratic. If isocratic works for you, it’s fantastic. You’re ahead of the game. You get the best separation under isocratic conditions, but gradients give us versatility and give us the ability to clean a column.
Conclusion: How to Make The Decision
In summary, the decision to use a gradient or isocratic approach in chromatography hinges on the specific requirements of your analysis. If your compounds share similar hydrophobicities, an isocratic method may suffice. However, for a broader range of compounds or to ensure thorough cleaning of the column, HPLC gradients offer a versatile solution. Understanding your analytical needs and the properties of your compounds is key to choosing the most effective chromatography method.
Reach out to us here if you have any questions.
